Olaf now outranks Anna. Here's why, plus 2 more surprises.
A snowman, the richest duck alive and a rusty tow truck are beating bigger names. Each one found a different way up.
Olaf passed his big sister Anna on Oct 24 and hasn't looked back. He's #23 on our character chart, Anna is #27, and Elsa still rules the castle at #3.
Two more names surprised us. Scrooge McDuck sits at #15, ahead of Cinderella, Snow White and Jasmine, even though 59 characters sold more cards than he did in the last 30 days. And Mater, the rusty tow truck from Cars, just hit #28, his best spot yet.
Our chart, the Mickey Index, ranks characters by what their cards sell for next to the same Mickey Mouse card. It rewards price. So a character can sell fewer cards and still climb, and these three each found their own way up.
Scrooge: the duck who skipped two years
Start with the cheap stuff. The 2023 Scrooge #87 sells for a typical $10, and the 2026 Scrooge #118 goes for $1.89. That's only 14 and 13 sales in the last 30 days, so grain of salt.
Ungraded, last 30 days, shipping included.
The richest duck in the world has a card for less than a coffee. His rank comes from the top shelf.
Over half his score rests on 9 sales of cards numbered /10 or lower in the past year. A 2026 Scrooge SuperFractor 1/1 (the gold one-of-one, the rarest card in the set) sold for $9,520 on Aug 24. Two 2026 Sapphire Red /5 cards went for $4,157 and $4,005 on Sep 2.
Here's why those cards bring so much. Scrooge has a base card in 2023 and 2026 and none in 2024 or 2025. Donald, his nephew, has one in all four years. So there are about half as many rare Scrooge cards in the world, and every DuckTales fan chasing a Scrooge /5 is bidding on the same few copies.
Below the top shelf he prices like family. In the 2026 set his Purple /75 sells for a typical $58 against Donald's $62, his Aqua /199 is $16 for both, and his Magenta /399 is $15 for both. Those run since the set came out, so they're rough.
Our read: Scrooge is a scarce character with fans who grew up on DuckTales, and scarce plus loved is how you reach #15 on 135 sales. Nine big sales is still a thin stack, so his spot could slip if the next rare Scrooge sells low.
Olaf: same sales, higher price
Olaf and Anna sell about the same number of cards: 192 for Olaf and 184 for Anna in the last 30 days. Olaf's cost more.
The 2023 Olaf #74 sells for a typical $7.99 on 19 sales. The 2023 Anna #9 sells for $6.48 on 36. The 2024 cards go the same way, $3.88 for Olaf and $2.77 for Anna, on only 8 and 9 sales. In 2026 they're dead even at about $1.60.
At the very top it's close. Anna owns the biggest slab, a 2023 Anna Gold Wave /50 graded PSA 10 at $9,320 in September. Olaf's best was a 2026 Olaf SuperFractor 1/1 at $10,000 on Sep 1.
Why the snowman? We can't prove it from sales alone. Our guess: Olaf is the Frozen character kids pick first, and a lot of families start with the 2023 set. Turns out some people really are worth melting for.
Mater: Cars turned 20
Mater climbed from #31 on Oct 11 to #28 on Nov 1, his best rank since the chart started.
Cars came out in June 2006, and the 2026 set throws it a birthday party with a Cars 20th anniversary insert (a bonus card design outside the main set). A Mater Meets Lightning SuperFractor 1/1 from that insert sold for $1,545 on Oct 25.
His everyday card did most of the climbing. The 2023 Mater #60 sells for a typical $10.43 on 16 sales. That beats the 2023 Olaf and Anna, and it's about half the 2023 Lightning McQueen #95 at $20.50 on 35 sales.
Ungraded, last 30 days, shipping included.
Three weeks is a short climb, so take the trend with a grain of salt. Our read: the birthday put Mater back in front of Cars fans, and the tow truck is towing his price up with him.
One more, with care: live-action Stitch
Stitch from the 2025 live-action Lilo & Stitch movie ranks #20 on only 41 sales in 30 days, #218 by cards sold. His base card #200 sells for about $3.47 on 8 sales. That's the shakiest rank on the board, so we'd treat it as a maybe.
What it means for your next buy
The surprise names share a shape: cheap base cards and pricey rare ones. If you love one of them, that's a good setup.
For Scrooge, the 2026 #118 under $2 is a good buy and the cheapest way into a top-15 character. The 2023 #87 around $10 is fair. $15 or more is an overpay, but if DuckTales was your childhood, go for it.
For Frozen fans, the 2023 Anna #9 at $6.48 is the better deal of the two sisters. The 2023 Olaf #74 is fair at about $8.
For Cars fans, the 2023 Mater #60 near $10 is a good buy next to Lightning at $20.50.
Shop the cards in this article
Links go to eBay. We may earn a small commission if you buy, at no cost to you.