Mickey's PSA 10 sells for 2.5x the same card in a CGC 10
Same mouse, same perfect grade, different slab. Here's what each grading company's label is worth, and where the bargains hide.
A 2023 Mickey Mouse #1 in a PSA 10 slab sells for a typical $1,094 (136 sales in the last year). The same card in a CGC 10 goes for $427 (23 sales). Same mouse, same grade, about 2.5 times the price.
Mickey is no fluke. Across 39 cards where both slabs sold at least twice, a CGC 10 brought about 35 cents for every dollar a PSA 10 brought. An SGC 10 brought about 42 cents, on 22 cards.
Grading means mailing a card to a company that checks it, scores it from 1 to 10 and seals it in a hard plastic case called a slab. PSA, CGC, SGC and BGS (Beckett) are the big names. A 10 is a gem, the top grade.
How we compared them
We matched cards one at a time: same character, same set year, same version (the base card or one exact color). For each card we took the typical sale of each grade over the last 12 months, shipping included, and compared them. A grade needed at least 2 sales on that card to count.
That keeps a $1,000 Mickey from being stacked against a $20 Sulley. A year is a long window and prices move inside it, so treat every ratio here as a rounded guide.
Typical sale over the last 12 months, shipping included. Raw is 659 sales, CGC 10 is 23, PSA 10 is 136.
Why PSA gets the premium
PSA handles 93% of graded Topps Chrome Disney sales: 29,467 of the 31,622 slabbed cards sold in the last year. CGC has about 4% (1,156 sales) and SGC about 1.5% (468).
Our read: the gap comes from the buyers. Far more collectors shop for PSA slabs, so a PSA 10 has more people bidding on it and is easier to resell. Every one of these companies grades cards carefully. The market has picked a favorite, and it pays for the red label.
Here's the wild part. A PSA 9 sells for about 35 cents per PSA 10 dollar, across 1,008 cards. That's the same share a CGC 10 gets. On price alone, the market treats a CGC 10 a lot like a PSA 9.
| Grade | Compared with | Cents per dollar | Cards |
|---|---|---|---|
| CGC 10 | PSA 10 | 35¢ | 39 |
| SGC 10 | PSA 10 | 42¢ | 22 |
| PSA 9 | PSA 10 | 35¢ | 1,008 |
| CGC 9 | PSA 9 | 68¢ | 27 |
| SGC 9.5 | PSA 9 | 80¢ | 12 |
| CGC 9 | PSA 8 | $1.22 | 10 |
| PSA 8 | PSA 9 | 62¢ | 201 |
So, is an SGC 9 worth a PSA 8?
Honest answer: we can't tell yet. SGC 9s are rare in Disney Chrome, with 65 sales all year, and only 2 cards had an SGC 9 and a PSA 8 each sell twice. That's too few to call, so take anything you hear either way with a grain of salt.
CGC 9s give us more to work with. On 10 cards with both, a CGC 9 sold for about 1.2 times a PSA 8 and came out ahead on 6 of the 10. Next to a PSA 9, a CGC 9 brought about two thirds of the price (27 cards), and an SGC 9.5 about 80% (12 cards).
So a 9 from another company usually tops a PSA 8 and trails a PSA 9. Our guess is an SGC 9 lands in that same spot. We'll know once more of them sell.
Two recent sales of the same card, shipping included.
Each step down the PSA ladder costs plenty too. A PSA 8 sells for about 62% of a PSA 9 (201 cards), which puts it near a fifth of a PSA 10. The 2024 Mickey Mouse #1 shows it: a PSA 10 sold for $856.20 on Oct 28 and a PSA 8 for $106.50 on Sep 22.
When the other slabs close the gap
The red label loses sometimes. A CGC 10 sold for more than the PSA 10 of the same card on 7 of the 39 cards we could compare, and an SGC 10 did it on 3 of 22.
The 2024 Mickey Mouse Refractor #1 came close this fall. A refractor is the shiny rainbow version of the card, and this one carries no serial number (roughly 1,100 made). An SGC 10 sold for $1,506 on Oct 4. PSA 10s sold for $1,930 on Oct 12 and $2,250 on Oct 20. That's 67 to 78 cents on the PSA dollar, far closer than the usual 42.
Single sales, shipping included.
What it means for your next buy
Want a gem Mickey for your PC and have no plans to sell? A CGC 10 or SGC 10 is a great buy. You get a perfect-grade card for about a third to two fifths of the PSA price. Bibbidi-bobbidi-bargain.
If resale matters, the PSA 10 has the most buyers waiting, and the price shows it. Paying up for the red label is fair. Just know that's what you're paying for.
And if a CGC 10 is listed near PSA 10 money, check the comps first. On most cards that's an overpay. If it's your kid's favorite character and the exact copy you want, PC away.
Shop the cards in this article
Links go to eBay. We may earn a small commission if you buy, at no cost to you.